| Country/Territory(Year) | Name | Title as per National | Age of Contentest |
| Finland(1952) | Armi Kuusela | Suomen Neito 1952 | 17 |
| France(1953) | Christiane Martel | Miss Cinemonde 1953 | 17 |
| United States(1954) | Miriam Stevenson | Miss USA 1954 | 21 |
| Sweden(1955) | Hillevi Rombin | Miss Sweden 1955 | 21 |
| United States(1956) | Carol Morris | Miss USA 1956 | 20 |
| Peru(1957) | Gladys Zender | Miss Peru 1957 | 17 |
| Colombia(1958) | Luz Marina Zuluaga | Virreina Colombia 1957 | 19 |
| Japan(1959) | Akiko Kojima | Miss Japan 1959 | 22 |
| United States(1960) | Linda Bement | Miss USA 1960 | 18 |
| Germany(1961) | Marlene Schmidt | Miss Germany 1961 | 23 |
| Argentina(1962) | Norma Nolan | Miss Argentina 1962 | 24 |
| Brazil(1963) | Leda Maria Vargas | Miss Brazil 1963 | 18 |
| Greece(1964) | Corinna Tsopei | Star Hellas 1964 | 20 |
| Thailand(1965) | Apasra Hongsakula | Miss Thailand 1964 | 18 |
| Sweden(1966) | Margareta Arvidsson | Miss Sweden 1966 | 18 |
| United States(1967) | Sylvia Hitchcock | Miss USA 1967 | 21 |
| Brazil(1968) | Martha Vasconcellos | Miss Brazil 1968 | 20 |
| Philippines(1969) | Gloria Diaz | Pilipinas Universe 1969 | 18 |
| Puerto Rico(1970) | Marisol Malaret | Miss Puerto Rico 1970 | 20 |
| Lebanon(1971) | Georgina Rizk | Miss Lebanon 1970 | 18 |
| Australia(1972) | Kerry Anne Wells |
Miss Australia 1972 | 20 |
| Philippines(1973) | Margie Moran | Binibining Pilipinas - Universe 1973 | 19 |
| Spain(1974) | Amparo Munoz | Miss Espana 1973 | 20 |
| Finland(1975) | Anne Marie Pohtamo | Miss Suomi 1975 | 19 |
| Israel(1976) | Rina Messinger | Miss Israel 1976 | 20 |
| Trinidad and Tobago(1977) | Janelle Commissiong | Miss Trinidad & Tobago 1977 | 24 |
| South Africa(1978) | Margaret Gardiner | Miss Republic of South Africa 1978 | 18 |
| Venezuela(1979) | Maritza Sayalero | Miss Venezuela 1979 | 18 |
| United States(1980) | Shawn Weatherly | Miss USA 1980 | 20 |
| Venezuela(1981) | Irene Saez | Miss Venezuela 1981 | 19 |
| Canada(1982) | Karen Dianne Baldwin | Miss Canada 1982 | 18 |
| New Zealand(1983) | Lorraine Downes | Miss New Zealand 1983 | 19 |
| Sweden(1984) | Yvonne Ryding | Miss Sweden 1984 | 21 |
| Puerto Rico(1985) | Deborah Carthy-Deu | Miss Puerto Rico 1985 | 19 |
| Venezuela(1986) | Barbara Palacios | Miss Venezuela 1986 | 22 |
| Chile(1987) | Cecilia Bolocco | Miss Chile 1987 | 22 |
| Thailand(1988) | Porntip Nakhirunkanok | Miss Thailand 1988 | 20 |
| Netherlands(1989) | Angela Visser | Miss Holland 1988 | 22 |
| Norway(1990) | Mona Grudt | Norske Miss Universe 1990 | 19 |
| Mexico(1991) | Lupita Jones | Senorita Mexico 1990 | 23 |
| Namibia(1992) | Michelle McLean | Miss Namibia 1991 | 19 |
| Puerto Rico(1993) | Dayanara Torres | Miss Puerto Rico 1993 | 18 |
| India(1994) | Sushmita Sen | Femina Miss India 1994 | 18 |
| United States(1995) | Chelsi Smith | Miss USA 1995 | 21 |
| Venezuela(1996) | Alicia Machado | Miss Venezuela 1995 | 19 |
| United States(1997) | Brook Lee | Miss USA 1997 | 26 |
| Trinidad and Tobago(1998) | Wendy Fitzwilliam | Miss Trinidad and Tobago Universe 1998 | 25 |
| Botswana(1999) | Mpule Kwelagobe | Miss Botswana Universe 1999 | 19 |
| India(2000) | Lara Dutta | Femina Miss India 2000 | 22 |
| Puerto Rico(2001) | Denise Quiñones | Miss Puerto Rico Universe 2001 | 20 |
| Russia(2002) | Oxana Fedorova | Miss Russia 2001 | 24 |
| Panama(2002) | Justine Pasek | Senorita Panama 2001 | 23 |
| Dominican Republic(2003) | Amelia Vega | Miss Republica Dominicana 2002 | 18 |
| Australia(2004) | Jennifer Hawkins | Miss Australia 2004 | 20 |
| Canada(2005) | Natalie Glebova | Miss Universe Canada 2005 | 23 |
| Puerto Rico(2006) | Zuleyka Rivera | Miss Puerto Rico Universe 2006 | 18 |
| Japan(2007) | Riyo Mori | Miss Universe Japan 2007 | 20 |
| Venezuela(2008) | Dayana Mendoza | Miss Venezuela 2007 | 22 |
| Venezuela(2009) | Stefania Fernandez |
Miss Venezuela 2008 | 18 |
| Mexico(2010) | Ximena Navarrete | Nuestra Belleza Mexico 2009 | 22 |
| Angola(2011) | Leila Lopes | Miss Angola 2010 | 25 |
| United States(2012) | Olivia Culpo | Miss USA 2012 | 20 |
| Venezuela(2013) | Gabriela Isler | Miss Venezuela 2012 | 25 |
| Colombia(2014) | Paulina Vega | Senorita Colombia 2013-2014 | 22 |
| Philippines(2015) | Pia Wurtzbach | Miss Universe Philippines 2015 | 26 |
| France(2016) | Iris Mittenaere | Miss France 2016 | 24 |
| South Africa(2017) | Demi-Leigh Nel-Peters | Miss South Africa 2017 | 22 |
| Philippines(2018) | Catriona Gray | Miss Universe Philippines 2018 | 24 |
| South Africa(2019) | Zozibini Tunzi | Miss South Africa 2019 | 26 |
| Mexico(2020) | Andrea Meza | Mexicana Universal 2020 | 26 |
| India(2021) | Harnaaz Sandhu | Miss Diva Universe 2021 | 21 |